Nel 1930 tornò la sfida tra i vincitori della Football League e quelli della FA Cup e, con poche eccezioni, questo formato è rimasto fino ai giorni nostri. Eccezioni degne di nota sono quelle del 1950, che vide la sfida tra la squadra inglese convocata per i mondiali del Brasile e una squadra della Football Association reduce da un tour in Canada e quella del 1961, quando il Tottenham Hotspur, il primo team del XX secolo a ottenere il Double, giocò contro una rappresentativa della Football Association, vincendo per 3 a 2.
[table class=”table-bordered” caption=”Charity/Community Shield – Titoli per squadra” width=”450″ colwidth=”250|100|100″ colalign=”left|center|center”]
Squadra,Titoli,Secondi posti
Arsenal,12,7
Tottenham Hotspur,7,2
Chelsea,4,6
West Ham United,1,2
Queens Park Rangers,0,2
Corinthian,0,1
Wimbledon,0,1
[/table]
[table class=”table-bordered” caption=”Charity/Community Shield – Albo d’oro” width=”600″ colwidth=”100|350|150″ colalign=”left|left|center”]
Anno,Finale,Risultato
1908,Manchester United-Queens Park Rangers,1-1
1908 (R),Manchester United-Queens Park Rangers,4-0
1909,Newcastle United-Northampton Town,2-0
1910,Brighton and Hove Albion-Aston Villa,1-0
1911,Manchester United-Swindon Town,8-4
1912,Blackburn Rovers-Queens Park Rangers,2-1
1913,English Professionals XI-English Amateurs XI,7-2
1914-1919,Non disputata per la Prima Guerra Mondiale,
1920,West Bromwich Albion-Tottenham Hotspur,2-0
1921,Tottenham Hotspur-Burnley,2-0
1922,Huddersfield Town-Liverpool,1-0
1923,English Professionals XI-English Amateurs XI,2-0
1924,English Professionals XI-English Amateurs XI,3-1
1925,English Amateurs XI-English Professionals XI,6-1
1926,English Amateurs XI-English Professionals XI,6-3
1927,Cardiff City-Corinthian,2-1
1928,Everton-Blackburn Rovers,2-1
1929,English Professionals XI-English Amateurs XI,3-0
1930,Arsenal-Sheffield Wednesday,2-1
1931,Arsenal-West Bromwich Albion,1-0
1932,Everton-Newcastle United,5-3
1933,Arsenal-Everton,3-0
1934,Arsenal-Manchester City,4-0
1935,Sheffield Wednesday-Arsenal,1-0
1936,Sunderland-Arsenal,2-1
1937,Manchester City-Sunderland,2-0
1938,Arsenal-Preston North End,2-1
1939-1947,Non disputata per la Seconda Guerra Mondiale,
1948,Arsenal-Manchester United,4-3
1949,Portsmouth-Wolverhampton Wanderers,1-1† Titolo condiviso
1950,English World Cup XI-English FA Canadian TouringXI,4-2
1951,Tottenham Hotspur-Newcastle United,2-1
1952,Manchester United-Newcastle United,4-2
1953,Arsenal-Blackpool,3-1
1954,Wolverhampton Wanderers-West Bromwich Albion,4-4† Titolo condiviso
1955,Chelsea-Newcastle United,3-0
1956,Manchester United-Manchester City,1-0
1957,Manchester United-Aston Villa,4-0
1958,Bolton Wanderers-Wolverhampton Wanderers,4-1
1959,Wolverhampton Wanderers-Nottingham Forest,3-1
1960,Burnley-Wolverhampton Wanderers,2-2† Titolo condiviso
1961,Tottenham Hotspur-FA Selected XI,3-2
1962,Tottenham Hotspur-Ipswich Town,5-1
1963,Everton-Manchester United,4-0
1964,Liverpool-West Ham United,2-2† Titolo condiviso
1965,Manchester United-Liverpool,2-2† Titolo condiviso
1966,Liverpool-Everton,1-0
1967,Manchester United-Tottenham Hotspur,3-3† Titolo condiviso
1968,Manchester City-West Bromwich Albion,6-1
1969,Leeds United-Manchester City,2-1
1970,Everton-Chelsea,2-1
1971,Leicester City-Liverpool,1-0
1972,Manchester City-Aston Villa,1-0
1973,Burnley-Manchester City,1-0
1974,Liverpool-Leeds United,1-1* (6-5 dcr)
1975,Derby County-West Ham United,2-0
1976,Liverpool-Southampton,1-0
1977,Manchester United-Liverpool,0-0† Titolo condiviso
1978,Nottingham Forest-Ipswich Town,5-0
1979,Liverpool-Arsenal,3-1
1980,Liverpool-West Ham United,1-0
1981,Aston Villa-Tottenham Hotspur,2-2† Titolo condiviso
1982,Liverpool-Tottenham Hotspur,1-0
1983,Manchester United-Liverpool,2-0
1984,Everton-Liverpool,1-0
1985,Everton-Manchester United,2-0
1986,Everton-Liverpool,1-1† Titolo condiviso
1987,Everton-Coventry City,1-0
1988,Liverpool-Wimbledon,2-1
1989,Liverpool-Arsenal,1-0
1990,Liverpool-Manchester United,1-1† Titolo condiviso
1991,Arsenal-Tottenham Hotspur,0-0† Titolo condiviso
1992,Leeds United-Liverpool,4-3
1993,Manchester United-Arsenal,1-1* (5-4 dcr)
1994,Manchester United-Blackburn Rovers,2-0
1995,Everton-Blackburn Rovers,1-0
1996,Manchester United-Newcastle United,4-0
1997,Manchester United-Chelsea,1-1* (4-2 dcr)
1998,Arsenal-Manchester United,3-0
1999,Arsenal-Manchester United,2-1
2000,Chelsea-Manchester United,2-0
2001,Liverpool-Manchester United,2-1
2002,Arsenal-Liverpool,1-0
2003,Manchester United-Arsenal,1-1* (4-3 dcr)
2004,Arsenal-Manchester United,3-1
2005,Chelsea-Arsenal,2-1
2006,Liverpool-Chelsea,2-1
2007,Manchester United-Chelsea,1-1* (3-0 dcr)
2008,Manchester United-Portsmouth,0-0* (3-1 dcr)
2009,Chelsea-Manchester United,2-2* (4-1 dcr)
2010,Manchester United-Chelsea,3-1
2011,Manchester United-Manchester City,3-2
2012,Manchester City-Chelsea,3-2
2013,Manchester United-Wigan Athletic,2-0
[/table]